MJAAR

Black is Not a Color: A Philosophical, Scientific, and Decolonial Inquiry into Essence, Origin, and the Epistemology of Blackness

Arinaitwe Julius, Asiimwe Isaac Kazaara


Abstract

This study undertook a multi-layered philosophical, scientific, and decolonial investigation into the nature, classification, and epistemological positioning of Blackness both as a physical phenomenon and as a socially constructed identity marker. The central thesis posed that Black, as understood in the dominant Western chromatic tradition, is not a color in the optical-scientific sense, yet has been systematically weaponized as a racial category through colonial knowledge systems that conflate pigmentation, light absorption, and human identity in deeply oppressive ways. Drawing on a mixed-methods theoretical and quantitative framework, the study surveyed 420 participants across academic, community, and professional contexts using validated psychometric instruments designed to measure the Perception of Blackness as Essence (PBE), Coloniality of Color Knowledge (CCK), Epistemic Marginalization Index (EMI), Scientific Literacy Score (SLS), and Decolonial Identity Affirmation (DIA). Univariate analyses revealed that respondents demonstrated moderate-to-high levels of essentialist thinking about Blackness (Mean PBE = 3.84, SD = 0.91), while scientific literacy scores remained comparatively lower (Mean SLS = 3.42, SD = 1.02), suggesting a disconnect between scientific understanding and culturally inherited racial epistemologies. Bivariate Pearson correlation analyses confirmed strong, statistically significant positive associations among coloniality of knowledge, epistemic marginalization, and essentialist perceptions of Blackness, while scientific literacy demonstrated consistent negative correlations with essentialist constructs. Structural Equation Modelling (SEM) revealed that Coloniality of Color Knowledge exerted a significant total indirect effect on Perception of Blackness as Essence through both epistemic marginalization and decolonial identity affirmation (β = 0.394, p < .001), with the model demonstrating excellent fit indices (CFI = 0.964, RMSEA = 0.048, SRMR = 0.051). The findings affirmed that the epistemological treatment of Black as a racial essence is a colonial artifact sustained by knowledge structures that suppress both scientific literacy and decolonial self-affirmation. The study recommended decolonizing science education curricula, investing in community-based epistemic reclamation programs, and mainstreaming decolonial identity affirmation as an instrument of cognitive and social liberation.

Keywords

Blackness epistemology decoloniality color science structural equation modelling epistemic marginalization coloniality of knowledge
Metropolitan Journal of Academic and Applied Research

Cite This Article

Arinaitwe Julius & Asiimwe Isaac Kazaara (2026). Black is Not a Color: A Philosophical, Scientific, and Decolonial Inquiry into Essence, Origin, and the Epistemology of Blackness. Metropolitan Journal of Academic and Applied Research, 5(3). https://journals.miu.ac.ug/pages/article.php?article_id=313

More in This Issue

View full issue →
26
Racing the Clock: Cultivating a Time Mindset as a Foundational Skill for Learners in Uganda’s Competence- Based Curriculum
Arinaitwe Julius, Ariyo Gracious Kazaara
Time mindset competence-based curriculum Uganda foundational skills
27
Racing the Clock: Cultivating a Time Mindset as a Foundational Skill for Learners in Uganda’s CompetenceBased Curriculum
Arinaitwe Julius1 , Ariyo Gracious Kazaara2
Time mindset competence-based curriculum Uganda foundational skills
28
Reclaiming Timbuktu: A Critical Analysis of the Pre-Colonial Center of African Scholarly Production
Dr. Arinaitwe Julius1 , Asiimwe Isaac Kazaara2
Pre-Colonial Center Africa and Scholarly Production
29
Religion and Human Essence: A Critical Examination of the "Dehumanization" Thesis in Christian Contexts
Asiimwe Isaac Kazaara1 , Musiimenta Nancy2
Dehumanization Christian contexts human dignity doctrinal rigidity
30
Say Yes and Learn Later”: Confidence as a Core Competency and the Imperative for Educational Reform in Uganda
Arinaitwe Julius1 , Musiimenta Nancy2
self-confidence educational reform Uganda competency-based learning